Research Report
Hammer the Scammer: The Fraud Defense Playbook
COMMISSIONED BY THE LEAGUE OF CREDIT UNIONS & AFFILIATES/LEVERAGE
Account takeover. AI-powered phishing. Social engineering. Faster payments. Compromised credentials. Fraudsters are attacking credit union members from more directions and increasingly finding ways around traditional defenses.
The numbers show what’s at stake. Cornerstone Advisors’ Performance Vault™ data found median annual fraud losses of $10.64 per checking account for U.S. credit unions, up more than 10% from the prior year. At the same time, account takeover emerged as the most significant fraud threat among the credit unions Cornerstone interviewed.
In this playbook, Cornerstone Advisors combines industry benchmarks, interviews with high-performing credit unions and practical strategies to help institutions strengthen their defenses. The playbook makes one thing clear: Fraud is no longer a technology problem that can be handed off to one department. Winning requires an enterprise response that connects authentication, payment controls, technology, staffing, member education, collaboration and performance measurement.
What You’ll Learn in This Report
- Why account takeover demands a new defense. Fraudsters are combining stolen credentials, compromised devices and social engineering to circumvent traditional authentication and exploit multiple payment channels.
- Where traditional authentication falls short. Nearly all interviewed institutions use SMS one-time passcodes, while only a minority reported using biometrics and roughly one-third behavioral analytic.
- How AI can strengthen fraud detection without replacing human judgment. Behavioral technology can analyze device patterns, navigation, typing cadence and transactional behavior to identify risk that passwords and one-time passcodes alone can miss.
- Five plays credit unions can put into action. The report covers biometric and behavioral validation, funds-availability practices, card-number security, recurring member education, and participation in fraud consortiums and peer network.
Report Stats At a Glance
$10.64
Median annual fraud loss per credit union checking account, including debit- and credit-card fraud—an increase of more than 10% from the prior year.
0.0550%
Median credit-card net fraud losses as a percentage of purchase volume, compared with 0.0411% for debit cards.
59%
Higher click rates generated when bad actors used AI to draft phishing emails.
Ready to See Real Results With Your Financial Institution?
Solutions from Cornerstone Advisors
Artificial Intelligence
Turn AI into measurable business outcomes. Cornerstone's Artificial Intelligence Accelerator helps banks and credit unions move from experimentation to execution by aligning strategy, governance, data, and technology. Prioritize high-impact use cases, optimize existing AI investments, and deploy scalable solutions that deliver lasting operational and financial results.
Digital
We help you drive measurable value from your digital investments. Our expert team partners with you to deliver end-to-end support across your key digital initiatives—from strategy to execution. Whether you're modernizing legacy platforms, optimizing digital contracts or scaling new technologies, we ensure every step is aligned to your business objectives. With decades of experience and deep industry insights, we help you make smarter digital decisions and turn your technology partnerships into a true competitive advantage.
Vendor Management
Managing vendors can be one of the most challenging tasks for financial institutions. That’s why Cornerstone offers “white glove,” turnkey vendor management services where we do it all for you. Our Vendor Management offering delivers significant benefits, including decreased expenses, improved vendor performance and reduced risk. Additionally, we support these services through Vendor Vault™, our robust technology platform for managing the entire vendor lifecycle.
Performance
Cornerstone’s Performance solutions provide a wide range of consulting expertise to help clients identify opportunities to increase efficiency and productivity across their entire organization, whether it’s enhancing the digital experience or optimizing payments. We leverage these services with our proprietary tools, including Performance Vault and Analytics Vault. Armed with unparalleled insider data analytics and benchmarking intel, your bank or credit union will gain the confidence to make sound, data-driven decisions.
About Cornerstone Advisors
For over 20 years, Cornerstone Advisors has delivered gritty insights, bold strategies and data-driven solutions to build smarter banks, credit unions and fintechs. From technology system selection and implementation to contract negotiations, vendor management, performance improvement programs, strategic planning, merger integration and enterprise program management, Cornerstone combines its expertise with proprietary data and research to help financial institutions thrive in today’s challenging environment. For more information, visit www.crnrstone.com, connect with us on LinkedIn and Youtube, and subscribe to GonzoBanker® for our opinionated take on all things banking.